It's not just that this show is about a serial killer cult. Spoilers ahead!
Spoiler alert!
When Sarah Fuller's "gay" neighbors kidnapped her.
When it happened: Episode 1, Season 1
Why it's WTF: One minute Paul and Jacob are bringing over pizza and holding Sarah's hand through her ordeal, the next they're breaking into her apartment through a jimmied tunnel and driving her to an untimely death. It's enough to make you never want to leave your house again. Ever.
WTF level on a scale of one to ten: 7
Source: fox.com
When this lady took off all her clothes and gouged out her own eye.
When it happened: Episode 1, Season 1
Why it's WTF: Aside from the fact that she revealed her body was covered in Edgar Allan Poe excerpts—how did she write all that out?!—this was one of the first moments when Joe Carroll’s incredible influence became clear.
WTF level on a scale of one to ten: 10
Source: forcesofgeek.com
When Emma kills her own mother in front of Jacob, and he's kind of turned on by it.
When it happened: Episode 2, Season 1
Why it's WTF: We get it, Emma's mother was a trollop. But to go ahead and knife her? Then bury her in the attic? And to become closer to your boyfriend because of it? Yo, that shit crazy.
WTF level on a scale of one to ten: 8
Source: thefollowing.wikia.com
